Surfshark Opinions

Recommendation

In my professional opinion, Surfshark is a better VPN than ProtonVPN, and is the better choice in most circumstances.

This comparison between ProtonVPN and SurfShark includes test data that was undertaken between 3 September and 3 November 2020.

Surfshark Overall Value. Put simply, Surfshark offers some of the best value in the market today, but only if you pick a six-month or two-year plan — the month-to-month subscription is a little pricey in our opinion, but those longer subscription durations are more than reasonable. And for that money, you’re actually getting quite a bit here. A pandemic can bring you to a dead-end in binge-watching — also, rewatching everything gets repetitive. In this case, a VPN lets you access global content that’s usually only available outside of your country, including foreign TV shows, movies, sports, and more! The gist of it is that Surfshark is going to hang on to your email address, your password, and gather anonymous application usage data. More than reasonable in our opinion, and we have to say — we really appreciate how upfront Surfshark is being right here. Their commitment to privacy really inspires confidence in their service.

Comparison Results

Privacy & Anonymity
(7.9)
(8.87)
Speed & Performance
(7.25)
(8.11)
Functionality & Application
(5.21)
(6.79)
Reputation & Support
(7.85)
(10)
Price & Value
(5.64)
(9.87)
Total Score
(6.77)
(8.73)

How is ProtonVPN better than SurfShark?

Surfshark is better than ProtonVPN in all aspects.

How is SurfShark better than ProtonVPN?

Surfshark offers better privacy, browsing and torrenting speeds, customer support, and unblocks Netflix in more countries than ProtonVPN.

Privacy & Anonymity

Which one offers better privacy?

Surfshark is better for privacy since they do not collect any logs. While it is unidentifiable, ProtonVPN collects the last connection timestamp data to restrict the number of simultaneous connections.

Privacy & Anonymity Comparison

Privacy & Anonymity
(7.9)
(8.87)
ConsiderationProtonVPNSurfShark
DNS Leak TestPassPass
WebRTC Leak TestPassPass
IP Leak TestPassPass
Protocols WindowsOpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCPOpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2, Shadowsocks, WireGuard
Protocols MacUDP, TCPOpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2, WireGuard
Protocols AndroidOpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2OpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2, Shadowsocks, WireGuard
Protocols iOSOpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2OpenVPN UDP, OpenVPN TCP, IKEv2
Killswitch WindowsYesYes
Killswitch MacYesYes
Killswitch AndroidYesYes
Killswitch iOSNoYes
Logs PolicyLast connection timestamp onlyNo logs collected
JurisdictionSwitzerlandBritish Virgin Islands

Speed & Performance

Which one is faster?

We tested the browsing and downloading speeds of both VPNs multiple times using different protocols. Surfshark’s OpenVPN - UDP protocol was the fastest with an impressive performance. Surfshark’s IKEv2 was marginally better than ProtonVPN’s OpenVPN - UDP, both showing above-average speeds.

Which one is better for downloading torrents?

We downloaded 163MB, 642MB, and 2.42GB files using Surfshark and ProtonVPN. Surfshark was significantly faster than ProtonVPN in all three tests.

Speed & Performance Comparison

Speed & Performance
(7.25)
(8.11)

Speed Test Results

Surf shark opinions live

* Higher scores are better. Progress bar versus best test result amongst all VPNs.

Network Bandwidth Download Speed (Average) 25 Tests
31.84Mbps
66.22Mbps
81.72Mbps
76.66Mbps
75.67Mbps
93.33Mbps
100MB File Download Speed (Average) 25 Tests
9.87MBps
6.41MBps
10.04MBps
7.83MBps
9.6MBps
11.97MBps
Torrent Download Speed (Average) 5 Tests
7.23MBps
6.18MBps
7.15MBps
7.08MBps
7.24MBps
9.29MBps

Functionality & Application

Which is better for geo-unblocking Netflix?

We tested both VPNs to see if they would let us watch geo-blocked Netflix content in fifteen countries. Surfshark was far better than ProtonVPN, unblocking Netflix Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Japan, South Korea, Netherlands, Sweden, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

ProtonVPN unblocked Netflix France, Germany, Japan, United Kingdom, and the United States.

Netflix Unblock Tests

CountryProtonVPNSurfShark
AustraliaFailSuccess
BrazilFailFail
CanadaFailSuccess
FranceSuccessSuccess
GermanySuccessSuccess
Hong KongFailFail
IndiaFailFail
IsraelFailFail
JapanSuccessSuccess
KoreaFailSuccess
MexicoFailFail
NetherlandsFailSuccess
SwedenFailSuccess
United KingdomSuccessSuccess
USASuccessSuccess
Free

Which one has better features?

Surfshark allows unlimited simultaneous connections while ProtonVPN allows only ten.

Functionality & Application Comparison

Functionality & Application
(5.21)

Surf Shark Opinions Online

(6.79)
ConsiderationProtonVPNSurfShark
UX / Ease of UseGreatGreat
Installation / OnboardingExcellentAverage
Split Tunneling WindowsYesYes
Split Tunneling MacNoNo
Split Tunneling AndroidYesYes
Split Tunneling iOSComing SoonComing Soon
Unblocks Netflix Score5/1510/15
Unblocks BBC iPlayerPassPass
ExtrasTor integration,CleanWeb - Blocks ads, malware, trackers, NoBorders - bypass internet restrictions
Number of Servers1019 +1700 +
Number of Countries with Servers5163
Maximum Number of Connections10Unlimited

Reputation & Support

Which one offers better support?

Surfshark offers live chat support while ProtonVPN offers only email support.

Which one is more trustworthy?

Surfshark has maintained a fairly clean reputation, with most users being happy with the service provided.

Proton has a good privacy reputation, being the same company behind the privacy focused email service, ProtonMail. However, there were rumors that ProtonVPN had dealings related to human resources with a firm called Tesonet, known for>ConsiderationProtonVPNSurfSharkReputationVery GoodExcellentSupport Response and QualityVery GoodExcellentSupport DocumentationExcellentExcellent

Price & Value

Which offers better value for money?

Surfshark offers better value for money considering the speeds, torrenting, and streaming compatibility. Their monthly plan is slightly costlier at $11.95 per month compared to ProtonVPN’s $10 per month. However, Surfshark’s one year plan costs only $71.88 while ProtonVPN’s one year plan costs $96.

Price & Value Comparison

Price & Value
(5.64)
(9.87)

Surf Shark Opinions Youtube

ConsiderationProtonVPNSurfShark
One Month Price ($USD)$10.00/month$11.95/month
One Year Deal (Price Per Month)$8.00/month$5.99/month
Two Year Deal (Price Per Month)$6.63/month$1.99/month

Great - 8.73 / 10

SurfShark

Surfshark Opinions On The Internet

Very Good - 6.77 / 10

ProtonVPN